The greatest college admissions blog posting EVER!!!!
But now that the puffery got your attention, it's probably sensible to examine what happened at/to MIT in fuller detail.
And let me first make a point: in no way am I attempting to impugn the body of work of Marilee Jones, who, until last week, was known as someone who tried to take the pressure off of this college admissions process.
I tend to filter this whole thing more into the Clinton lens than anything. In that I read the bumper stickers that say "When Clinton Lied, Nobody Died," and I do look back and think that we haven't had a cool president in 6-plus years, and the economy was in good shape and all that. But he did perjure himself, and was impeached. But he stayed in office.
Back to Ms. Jones. Her body of work was great. She asked for parents to take a collective chill pill, and kids to not worry too much. Both concepts are good ones.
But so is honesty. Coming clean. Looking yourself in the mirror and being able to fess up and believe that you are being true to yourself and others and the world in which you live.
We subscribe to a variety of codes of conduct, of ethics, of ways of doing things. I'm not talking about MIT's code of conduct, or the National Association's code of standards or guidelines. I'm talking about the generally accepted principles of why in the world it's not okay to give someone the finger or buy crack on the street or make crank phone calls. I'm talking about not making up your resume -- YES, I REALLY WAS A VP -- or being able to hold up a diploma that is real and was not ordered online and actually has a transcript behind it.
So the body of work is still there -- just like Clinton was still president from 93 through January of 01. I can't argue with it, nor can I pretend that Ms. Jones didn't have a little something to do with making this admissions world a little more open to guys like me (thus able to run a business that hopes to add transparency to this process, and doing so from the local Starbucks, natch).
But claiming to be something you aren't, a couple times over -- when that something (a degree) forms the very basis for what you are trying to help people do (get a degree) is, well, inexcusable.

